Paragon Legal
  • For Clients
    • How We Help
    • Our Approach
    • Our Attorneys
    • Practice Areas
    • FAQs
  • For Attorneys
    • The Paragon Experience
    • Our Hiring Process
    • Opportunities
    • Refer A Friend
    • FAQs
  • Insights
    • Articles
    • Reports
    • GC Sidebar
    • Case Studies
    • News & Events
    • Spotlights
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Our Commitment to Diversity & Inclusion
    • Careers at Paragon
    • Contact Us
  • Menu Menu
  • Employee Portal
  • Apply
  • Request An Attorney

Featured Insights

Interim Legal Counsel: Strategic Flexibility That Drives Impact

5 Ways to Help You Sell Your CFO on Interim Counsel Services

Client Profile: Tech Giant Rightsources Legal Talent to Stay on Top – A Growth Story

Categories

  • Articles
  • Reports
  • GC Sidebar
  • Case Studies
  • News & Events
  • Spotlights

Building a Legal Function From Scratch: A 12-Month Roadmap

November 11, 2026 | Articles
Silhouettes of professionals working in a modern glass office at dusk, representing a company building its in-house legal function from the ground up.

Key Takeaways

  • 46% of legal teams report being understaffed, which is the condition a first in-house hire inherits rather than an exception to plan around.
  • 40% of small legal departments name repeatable processes and playbooks as what drives their success, ahead of any other strategy.
  • 56% of legal leaders rank efficiency as their top priority, followed by technology at 45%, risk and compliance at 40%, and business alignment at 39%.
  • 33% credit alternative legal service providers, which include flexible legal talent, for recent wins, and 30% are shifting work away from big law.
  • 31% measure business outcomes, so the case for the function you’re building has to be made in numbers most departments never collect.

The work starts before you do. Contracts are being signed by sales, a vendor agreement is sitting in someone’s inbox, and a regulator’s letter is going to arrive whether or not anyone has decided who owns it. When a company hires its first lawyer, it isn’t starting a legal function. It’s naming one that already exists, and 46% of legal teams say they’re understaffed for the work in front of them.

Start by understanding the legal work already happening across the business, where the greatest risks and demands exist, and which resources are best suited to support that work. Evaluating the right mix of in-house counsel, outside law firms, flexible legal talent, and technology early on creates the foundation for building the right legal function.

Drawing on insights from general counsel who have built legal functions from the ground up and Paragon’s research, this 12-month roadmap offers a practical framework for assessing legal needs, building efficient processes, making strategic resourcing decisions, and demonstrating business value.

The timeline is a practical starting point, not a rigid formula. Priorities will vary based on a company’s size, industry, risk profile, and existing legal resources, and many of these activities will happen in parallel.

What a Legal Function Actually Is

A legal function is the people, processes, and technology a company uses to handle its legal work, whether or not any of it sits inside a legal department.

Every company has one. In a company without lawyers, it’s distributed: the finance lead approves contracts, the founder reads the terms of service, and outside counsel gets called when something breaks.

Hiring the first lawyer consolidates that work rather than creating it. The practical difference between a legal function and a legal department is that the department is the team on the org chart, and the function is everything the company does about legal risk, including the parts still happening in other people’s jobs and the legal services the company buys from outside, usually the largest line item nobody owns.

Sarah Wilson, General Counsel and Corporate Secretary at Circle, describes the role that creates:

Sarah Wilson

“General counsels are the dot connectors at companies. They know what all the functions are trying to achieve, and therefore you start to think about the implications of a decision outside of just a legal question.”

— Sarah Wilson, General Counsel and Corporate Secretary, Circle

What You Inherit Before Month One

Your first week is an audit, not a practice:

  • Signed contracts nobody has read since signing. Auto-renewals, assignment clauses, and liability caps agreed by people who were optimizing for closing the deal.
  • Outside counsel relationships that started as a favor and became a standing bill, usually with no scope and no budget.
  • Regulatory exposure nobody has mapped. Employment, privacy, and industry rules that applied the day the company crossed a headcount or revenue line.
  • A queue of requests routed to whoever answered last time, which is about to become a queue routed to you.

Transaction support, regulatory change, litigation, intellectual property, and managing external counsel make up most of what an in-house team handles. Established in-house legal teams split that load across people, and all five arrive at once for a solo lawyer.

Months 1 to 3: Triage and Take Inventory

Before investing in major new systems or expanding the team, understand what already exists. Address urgent legal risks while assessing the work, resources, and processes that will shape the function.”

  • Collect every contract. One folder, one spreadsheet, columns for counterparty, renewal date, termination window, and liability cap. This becomes your matter management system until you can afford software.
  • Interview each department head for 30 minutes. What legal work they send out, what they handle themselves, and what they have been avoiding.
  • Total the outside counsel spend. Pull 12 months of invoices and sort by matter type. The pattern in that spend is your first strategy document.
  • Evaluate how legal work is currently resourced. Identify which work is handled by in-house counsel, outside law firms, flexible legal talent, or technology. Assess whether each type of work is assigned to the right resource based on complexity, expertise, risk, continuity, and cost.
  • Name the three risks that would genuinely hurt. Write one page on each for the executive team. Naming the top three is what a first quarter can support.
  • Establish a baseline for measuring Legal’s value. Identify one metric that connects Legal’s work to a business priority, such as deal acceleration, risk mitigation, or business outcomes influenced, so you can demonstrate progress over time.

Eunice Buhler, General Counsel at G2, describes what the rebuild looked like for her:

Eunice Buhler

“We’ve spent hundreds of hours in rooms together, rebuilding our contracts from scratch and solving the company’s problems as they arise.”

— Eunice Buhler, General Counsel, G2

Resist the pull to answer every question that lands while the inventory is running. A solo lawyer who becomes the company’s legal advice help desk in month two never gets out of it, and the inventory is what tells you which questions should never have reached a lawyer.

Not everything you find needs to move to Legal right away. Transitioning work from the teams that handle it today can be a delicate process, and one lawyer can’t absorb it all in a quarter. Decide what comes under Legal immediately, usually the highest-risk work, and leave lower-stakes tasks where they are until you have the bandwidth to take them on.

Months 4 to 6: Build the Systems That Scale

Among small legal departments, 40% name repeatable processes and playbooks as the thing driving their success, more than any other strategy.

The Four Systems Worth Building First

Intake icon Intake

One form, one channel, one place requests go. Email and hallway requests are what make a solo lawyer feel understaffed before the volume says so.

Templates icon Templates

Standardized NDAs, customer agreements, and vendor agreements with clearly defined fallback positions, approval thresholds, and criteria for when legal review is required.

Signature and approval matrix icon A signature and approval matrix

Written rules for what needs a lawyer, what needs a manager, and what doesn’t require legal oversight. This one document takes more work off your desk than the other three combined.

Outside counsel policy icon An outside counsel policy

Establish clear guidelines for when to engage outside counsel, how matters are scoped, and how budgets and outcomes are managed.

Automation belongs here too, but narrowly. Legal technology earns a place in year one where it removes a step you’re doing by hand; legal tech bought for any other reason becomes shelfware. Contract lifecycle tools and AI review assistants handle intake triage, first-pass redlines, and clause extraction well, and every hour they return is an hour you spend on judgment. Buhler puts the balance this way: basic tasks can and should run through technology tools, which is what makes legal intuition matter more, not less.

Treat the rollout as change management rather than a launch. A signature matrix nobody follows is worse than none, because it creates a paper record of a process the company ignored. Walk it through each department, take the objections seriously, and revise once before it becomes policy.

Months 7 to 9: Refine Your Legal Resourcing Model

By month seven, the inventory is done, the systems exist, and the ceiling is you. By this stage, you should have a clearer picture of your legal workload, where additional capacity or specialized expertise is needed, and which resourcing model best fits each type of work.

Alisha Cieslak, who has twice been the first legal hire and built the function from the ground up both times, most recently as Chief Legal and Risk Officer at Gordon Food Service, sets the standard for this stage:

Alisha Cieslak

“To be successful, a GC has to apply the same operational rigor to the legal department that a COO applies to operations.”

— Alisha Cieslak, former Chief Legal and Risk Officer, Gordon Food Service

Her approach to staffing has three parts: generalists who understand a line of business and can own those relationships, specialists for the core areas that need deep institutional knowledge, and the technology, processes, and templates that support both. Law firms stay in the picture for her, and so does a resource she calls “a powerful and often underutilized resource for GCs”: flexible legal talent.

A third of legal teams credit alternative legal service providers, which include flexible legal talent, for recent wins, and 30% are moving work away from big law toward options that fit the task. Rightsourcing is the discipline of matching each type of work to the resource that should carry it, and for a department of one, it answers the only question that matters in month seven: what comes off your desk first.

Flexible legal talent can play an important role in this resourcing mix. Paragon’s experienced attorneys work directly within clients’ legal teams, providing embedded support across ongoing commercial work, specialized legal projects, and changing business demands. This model allows legal leaders to access experienced in-house expertise while complementing the capabilities of permanent employees and outside law firms. Many of these attorneys come from similar industries, so they bring best practices from comparable situations, and clients often find that experience points them to tools and processes they should be using.

Cieslak found that many of those attorneys were former in-house counsel who already understood the pace and expectations of working in-house, and that the teams she ran held their service levels through maternity leaves and attrition without overloading anyone.

Hiring is a different decision. Wilson screens for range over specialty, looking for agile attorneys who can pivot and advise across areas as the regulatory environment shifts. A second lawyer who only does one thing leaves you carrying everything else.

Months 10 to 12: Prove the Function’s Value

Only 31% of in-house legal departments measure business outcomes, and most report activity instead: contracts reviewed, matters closed, tickets cleared.

For small legal teams, the goal isn’t to track everything. It’s to identify a few meaningful metrics that demonstrate both how efficiently Legal operates and how its work supports business priorities. Contract turnaround time can show how Legal helps business teams move forward, stakeholder satisfaction can reveal the quality of those partnerships, and measures such as outside counsel spend, risk reduction, or business outcomes influenced can help demonstrate Legal’s broader contribution.

Start with the metrics most relevant to your organization’s goals, establish a baseline, and build from there.

What do you lead with when the CFO asks what the company got for its legal spend? Paragon’s guide to legal department metrics covers how the same number changes shape for finance, the CEO, and the board.

Use your first-year data to demonstrate how Legal’s work supports the business. Changes in outside counsel spend, contract turnaround time, and self-service resolution can show operational improvements. Connect those results to broader business outcomes, such as helping deals move faster, managing risk, or enabling business teams to operate more efficiently.

Mark Kahn started as the first lawyer at Segment and describes where that ended:

Mark Kahn

“At Segment, I started off as the first lawyer. I look at the team that we built there, both the overall company team and the legal-specific team, and by the time we got acquired by Twilio, the legal and privacy team was eight people, all fantastic folks.”

— Mark Kahn, General Counsel, Oakland Ballers

Eight people took years, not 12 months.

The 12-Month Roadmap at a Glance

Building a Legal Function: 12-Month Roadmap

PhaseWhat you doWhat you’ll have at the end
Months 1 to 3Inventory key contracts, interview department heads, and review outside counsel spend and top legal risks. Assess how legal work is currently resourced and establish a baseline metric for business value. Prioritize what moves to Legal now and what can wait until you have more bandwidth.A complete picture of the legal work the company is already doing, and where the money goes.
Months 4 to 6Build intake, templates, a signature and approval matrix, and an outside counsel policy. Add narrow automation for triage and first-pass review. Walk each system through the affected departments before it becomes policy.Four systems that let work move without you touching all of it.
Months 7 to 9Reassess how work is allocated across permanent in-house counsel, outside law firms, flexible talent, and technology. Identify where additional expertise or capacity is needed.Define what a second hire would own.Capacity that scales with demand, and a defined shape for the first addition to the team.
Months 10 to 12Evaluate the operational and business-impact metrics established earlier in the year. Compare outside counsel spend, contract turnaround, and self-serve resolution against your month-one baseline. Report results in business terms, connecting operational improvements to outcomes such as cost savings, risk reduction, or business efficiency.A clearer picture of Legal’s business impact and the resources needed to support the company’s next stage of growth.

Source: Paragon Legal analysis, with survey data from Proving Legal’s Value: A Practical Guide to Metrics That Matter and The Legal Portfolio Solution

What to Resist in Year One

Four things look like progress and cost more than they return at this stage:

  • A full legal operations build. Legal ops is a real discipline and its own hire, but a department of one doesn’t need a legal ops function. It needs four working processes.
  • Enterprise software bought on a three-year contract before you know your own volumes. A spreadsheet that tells the truth beats a platform configured around guesses.
  • Taking on internal investigations alone. These are specialist work with privilege consequences, and they arrive without warning. Decide in advance who you call.
  • Saying yes to everything to establish credibility. The requests you accept in month three define the department you’ll be running in month 12, and a function shaped entirely by other people’s urgency is hard to reshape later.

The shape of the team comes later, and it’s worth studying how other general counsel structured theirs before committing headcount to a model.

The operating side, including triage and process improvement, is covered in Paragon’s step-by-step guide to making a legal department work smarter.

Your First Year Is an Inventory, Then a System, Then a Case

A legal function built in the right order spends year one finding the work, year one’s second half routing it, and the last quarter proving what changed. Start with the contract register, build the four systems, then decide what leaves your desk. As your legal function grows, Paragon can help you build the right resourcing mix with experienced attorneys who integrate into your team, support complex and ongoing legal work, and provide the flexibility to adapt as business needs evolve.

Talk to Paragon about what you would hand off first.

Frequently Asked Questions

A legal function is the people, processes, and technology a company uses to handle its legal work, whether or not that work sits inside a legal department. Every company has one, even before it hires a lawyer.

The legal department is the team on the org chart. The legal function is everything the company does about legal risk, including the contract review and vendor approvals still happening inside other departments.

When outside counsel spend becomes unpredictable, contract volume starts delaying deals, or the business operates in a highly regulated industry. Another signal is sustained work going to outside counsel on matters an in-house lawyer is better placed to handle, such as day-to-day employment matters and commercial contracts. Most of these are measurable, and they tend to show up before anyone internally asks for a lawyer.

Build a contract register and total 12 months of outside counsel spend by matter type before building any process. The pattern in that spend tells you which system to build first.

Compare outside counsel spend, contract turnaround time, and the share of requests resolved without a lawyer against a month-one baseline. Those three are the direct result of what you built, which makes them defensible in a budget conversation.

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail
Back To List
Previous | Next

Featured Insights

Interim Legal Counsel: Strategic Flexibility That Drives Impact

5 Ways to Help You Sell Your CFO on Interim Counsel Services

Client Profile: Tech Giant Rightsources Legal Talent to Stay on Top – A Growth Story

Categories

  • Articles
  • Reports
  • GC Sidebar
  • Case Studies
  • News & Events
  • Spotlights

Subscribe to our newsletter

linkedin ico glassdoor icon facebook icon

Contact Us

2261 Market St.,
Suite 22304
San Francisco, CA 94114
info@paragonlegal.com
415.738.7870

For Clients

  • How We Help
  • Our Approach
  • Practice Areas
  • FAQs

For Attorneys

  • The Paragon Experience
  • Hiring Process
  • Opportunities
  • FAQs

About

  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • DEIB
  • Careers at Paragon
  • Contact Us

© 2026 Paragon Legal Group LLC. Paragon Legal is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice.

Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Accessibility Statement | Sitemap

Website design and developed by RainCastle Communications, Inc.

  • For Clients
    • How We Help
    • Our Approach
    • Our Attorneys
    • Practice Areas
    • FAQs
    • Back
  • For Attorneys
    • The Paragon Experience
    • Our Hiring Process
    • Opportunities
    • Refer A Friend
    • FAQs
    • Back
  • Insights
    • Articles
    • Reports
    • GC Sidebar
    • Case Studies
    • News & Events
    • Spotlights
    • Back
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Our Commitment to Diversity & Inclusion
    • Careers at Paragon
    • Contact Us
    • Back

    Quick Links

  • Employee Portal
  • Apply
  • Request An Attorney

Learn More About Attorney